Boston Marblehead Restaurant Reviews

BTR Boston: Jack-Tar American Tavern – Marblehead

jack tar bostonThe promise of $5 pizzas brought my friends and me to Jack-Tar. From 5-7 p.m. every day, Jack-Tar offers four pizzas from their menu for only $5 each! When I heard this, I thought we were going to a dingy pizza parlor with mediocre pizza. That was not the case at all!!

Jack-Tar is located in the heart of downtown Marblehead, a seaside town predating the United States. The historic town was preparing for the 4th of July by displaying its stars and stripes. My friends and I got to enjoy the patriotic atmosphere, the summer weather and our food from Jack-Tar’s garden patio, which makes up the majority of the restaurant’s seating.

jack tar boston

Our party of four ordered two pizzas (they’re about 12 inches in diameter) and one salad and it was the perfect amount of food. I’m going to describe our pizza first (and then come back to the appetizer) because it was just phenomenal!

jack tar boston

BBQ Chicken Pizza & Margarita Pizza

The Margarita was a classic pizza with fresh tomatoes, basil and mozzarella. I usually prefer pizzas with more toppings because most times, simple can be boring. This pizza, however, was absolutely fantastic!! It was hot out of the oven and the ingredients were so incredibly flavorful!

The BBQ Chicken pizza was also amazing! It was topped with chicken, caramelized onions, tomatoes and cilantro. The onions made this pizza. They were caramelized to sweet perfection!

If I lived in Marblehead, I’d try to come here every night for this pizza. I can honestly say that I’ve never had a pizza experience this memorable, and I’ve been to Italy. I think I can even say that this is the best pizza I’ve ever had. Not only was the flavor amazing, but the pizzas were also only $5 each!! It really doesn’t get any better than this. I’m now on the pursuit of a comparable pizza place in DC.

jack tar boston

Jack Tar Salad

And now for a review of the less memorable Jack Tar Salad ($8). I apologize for the blurriness of the photo… I didn’t realize it was out of focus! Anyway, the house salad consisted of various greens with grilled asparagus, tomatoes, almond slivers, goat cheese and a citrus vinaigrette. I’m not a fan of citrus flavor in anything except my water, so I thought the dressing was too lemony. The grilled asparagus was great; it had a nice smoky flavor. The goat cheese had a soft texture and a mild flavor, while the tomatoes added a hint of sweetness.

The food – a.k.a the pizza – here was FANTASTIC! Our party of four enjoyed an incredible meal at this sit-down restaurant for only $6 per person (tip included). Jack Tar’s pizza happy hour is an amazingly delicious deal you can’t afford to miss.

jack tar boston

outdoor seating

Jack-Tar American Tavern on Urbanspoon

You're gonna love these other posts!


  • Reply Le Beau Monde – Philadelphia | Better Than Ramen

    […] recently claimed that the pizza at Jack-Tar in Marblehead was the best pizza I have ever had. This crepe pizza may top Jack-Tar’s, but it definitely […]

    July 22, 2013 at 12:15 PM
  • Reply Better Than Ramen - BTR Philly - Creperie Beau Monde Review - Better Than Ramen

    […] recently claimed that the pizza at Jack-Tar in Marblehead was the best pizza I have ever had. This crepe pizza may top Jack-Tar’s, but it definitely […]

    December 21, 2015 at 2:14 PM
  • Leave a Reply

    Food Advertising by